10 Best Soft Cargo Carriers 2025 in the United States

The MeeFar Car Roof Bag XBEEK offers a generous 20 cubic feet of storage, making it suitable for family trips or large hauls. Made from 100% waterproof 700D PVC tarpaulin, it promises durability and resistance to tears, which is great for protecting your luggage from harsh weather conditions. The universal compatibility allows it to fit any car or SUV, whether or not you have a roof rack, adding to its versatility.

The inclusion of 10 reinforced straps and 6 security hooks ensures a secure fit, which is crucial for long drives. The anti-slip mat and luggage lock provide additional security and peace of mind. However, being a soft-shell carrier, it may not be as aerodynamic as hard-shell alternatives, potentially affecting fuel efficiency.

Installation is straightforward, thanks to the provided accessories and easy-to-follow instructions, and it can be folded compactly for storage when not in use. While the MeeFar roof bag is highly rated by users with a 4.4 out of 5-star rating, some might find the soft-shell design less protective against impacts compared to hard-shell options. Nonetheless, its affordability, ample space, and robust weather resistance make it a strong contender for anyone in need of extra cargo space.

The Thule 614 Pulse Rack is designed for those needing extra storage space on road trips or for adventurous outings. With a capacity of 14 cubic feet, it can accommodate various gear, including up to five snowboards, making it ideal for winter sports enthusiasts. The rugged plastic material ensures durability, protecting your belongings from the elements while also being water-resistant. The FastGrip quick-mount system is user-friendly, allowing for speedy installation in just minutes, which is a huge plus for busy families or individuals on the go.

One of the standout features is the central locking system, which enhances security, giving you peace of mind when leaving your belongings in the box. The passenger-side opening makes loading and unloading straightforward, reducing the hassle after a long day of travel. The external dimensions are spacious enough to fit larger items, but the height of 16 inches may require checking compatibility with your vehicle's roof clearance.

There are some drawbacks to consider. While it fits a decent amount of cargo, the 110 lbs load capacity means that heavier items may not be suitable for transport. Additionally, although it is made from durable materials, some concerns have been raised about the potential for wear and tear over time, especially with frequent use. The product is a bit bulky, which could impact aerodynamics and fuel efficiency compared to more streamlined designs.

The VENTURE 4TH Rooftop Cargo Carrier stands out due to its impressive 21 cubic feet capacity, which can accommodate around 10 carry-on bags, making it a solid choice for families or groups going on long trips. Crafted from military-grade PVC fabric, it promises durability and reliable protection against weather conditions, thanks to its waterproof build and SBS zippers with a protective flap. This is particularly beneficial for those frequently traveling in rainy or snowy regions.

Its universal fit is a real advantage, allowing it to attach to vehicles with or without roof racks, sidebars, or crossbars, making it versatile for a wide range of vehicle types. The installation is made straightforward with included door hooks and color-coded straps, supported by an instruction manual, making it user-friendly even for those less experienced with cargo carriers. Security is enhanced with heavy-duty cam buckles and reinforced stitching, plus a combination padlock for peace of mind against theft. However, its offered security features are quite standard and might not be sufficient for high-value items.

Despite its bulky dimensions (51" x 39" x 17"), which could affect car aerodynamics and fuel efficiency, its design is intended to minimize wind resistance. It includes a protective roof mat to prevent slippage and potential damage during travel. While the carrier is robust and reliable, weighing in at 11.5 pounds, which is relatively lightweight for its size, some users might find the setup initially intimidating, especially if their vehicle lacks roof racks. Also, the lifetime replacement guarantee is a reassuring touch, indicative of the manufacturer's confidence in the product's durability.

In essence, this rooftop cargo carrier is ideal for those needing substantial storage space, reliable weather protection, and a versatile mounting system, although it might not be the best fit for those prioritizing advanced security features or aerodynamic efficiency.